Let's dive into the world of 'Big Mistakes,' a Netflix crime comedy that has left audiences with a mix of emotions. This show, created by Dan Levy and Rachel Sennott, draws inspiration from the iconic 'Weeds,' a Showtime series that pushed the boundaries of dark comedy. While 'Weeds' had its fair share of silly moments, it also paved the way for a new genre of shows exploring ordinary people's descent into criminality. 'Big Mistakes' seems to be a direct descendant of this trend, with a similar blend of humor and suspense.
The story unfolds in New Jersey, following the ethnically and religiously diverse family of hardware store owner Linda (Laurie Metcalf). Linda's decision to run for mayor sets the stage for a series of events that involve her children, Nicky (Dan Levy) and Morgan (Taylor Ortega), in a web of criminal activities. The show's premise is intriguing, but as we delve deeper, some inconsistencies and choices become apparent.
One of the most striking aspects is the characters' motivations, or rather, the lack thereof. From Nicky's secret gay relationship within a religious context to Morgan's shoplifting adventure, the reasons behind their actions often feel like poorly considered happenstance. This choice of narrative direction might be a deliberate attempt to create a lighthearted tone, but it also leaves viewers questioning the depth of the characters' journeys.
Speaking of characters, the show boasts an impressive cast, with Laurie Metcalf's performance standing out as a highlight. Her ability to command attention and bring depth to her role is a testament to her talent. However, the same cannot be said for all the characters. Some, like the third sibling, feel underdeveloped and their actions lack a clear rationale.
As the series progresses, it becomes evident that 'Big Mistakes' is more focused on plot mechanics than character development. This is in contrast to shows like 'Schitt's Creek,' which evolved from broad comedy to a more nuanced exploration of relationships. 'Big Mistakes' seems to lack that emotional core, instead relying on clever dialogue and surprises to keep viewers engaged.
The show's writer, Dan Levy, seems to have a penchant for starting with broad humor and then dialing it back. While this strategy worked for 'Schitt's Creek,' 'Big Mistakes' doesn't quite hit the mark. The series lacks a point of improvement, leaving viewers with a sense of uncertainty about its direction.
Despite these criticisms, 'Big Mistakes' is not without its merits. The direction and editing are tight, creating a fast-paced and entertaining experience. The score, composed by Peaches and Nora Kroll-Rosenbaum, adds an extra layer of intensity, especially during implausible moments. The cast, especially Taylor Ortega and Laurie Metcalf, deliver compelling performances that keep viewers invested.
In conclusion, 'Big Mistakes' is a show that leaves a mixed impression. While it has its entertaining moments and a talented cast, the lack of logical character motivations and an emotional core might leave some viewers wanting more. It's a show that you might enjoy watching, but it's unlikely to leave a lasting impact. Personally, I think it's a missed opportunity to explore the potential of this genre, but I'm hopeful that future seasons could build upon the foundation and deliver a more satisfying experience.
